Going a–b

Going a–b

2 min read
Tech experts use the skateboard, scooter, bicycle,… metaphor to illustrate the idea of a minimum viable product. Not once did I hear someone point out, it is historically backwards. Why not?

The wisdom of the principle lies in making the product gradually more sophisticated, each iteration technically building on the previous one to deliver more value.

Standard MVP illustration

The problem is that the car came sixty years before the motorcycle

More important, neither were the first commercially successful application of the steam engine. It was the train.

Our intuition to start small and grow can be misleading. Technology is tricky because it tends to be big and expensive before it can be made smaller, cheaper, simpler, and better in many ways.

Range with a single charge diiagram
Muscle Steam ICE Electric
Horse Avg.: ~32–64 km
Max: ~160 km
– – –
Horse + carriage Avg.: ~16–48 km
Max: –
– – –
Bicycle Avg.: ~70–100 km
Max: ~200 km
– – –
Train – PoC: ~15.7 km
MVP: ~160 km
Max: ~800 km
PoC: –
MVP: ~800–965 km
Max: ~1,930 km
PoC: –
MVP: ~67 km
Max: 323 km
Car – PoC: ~32 km
MVP: ~50–80 km
Max: ~320 km
PoC: ~15 km
MVP: ~33 km
Max: 2,831 km
PoC: –
MVP: ~130 km
Max: 1,338 km
Motorcycle – – PoC: ~5–12 km
MVP: ~257 km
Max: 5,410 km
PoC: –
MVP: –
Max: 311 km
Aeroplane – – PoC: 260 m
MVP: ~39 km
Max: 40,212 km
–

Furthermore, improving long-distance travel is not just a matter of shorter time to the destination

The traveller also cares about convenience and safety. That is why before cars, people travelled between cities by horse and carriage. Not bicycle, scooter or skateboard.

The point is: to disrupt the existing solution, our product needs the cabin from the get-go. Otherwise, it will not address the same market, product category, or problem.

Good advice, bad analogy I suppose.

Ironic, considering stakeholders so often disagree about what the MVP should be.

To build the right thing is one thing.
To talk about it in the right way is another.

"One of the things I’ve always found is that you’ve got to start with the customer experience, and work backwards to the technology. You can’t start with the technology and try to figure out where are you going to try to sell it. And I’ve made this mistake probably more than anybody else in this room. And I’ve got the scar tissue to prove it."
— Steve Jobs, WWDC 1997